So the question is, which of the photos below will garner a more positive response from viewers?
Skin Tone I
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c42f6/c42f64a51cc6bb288f483e98ddf05d7284a5be5f" alt=""
Skin Tone II
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2b526/2b526f7aad01d7fbea2eede72d60a32bcf2a4029" alt=""
There is no right answer ! *grin*
You get as many different responses as the no of people you asked!
Lesson: Just stick to your judgment and produce what you think suits the sitter best. Never allow your sitter to compare!
Related Post: Good Skin Tone